Skip to content
VIA Studio

The First Question a CMO Should Ask: How Does This Business Actually Make Money?

Branding & Marketing
By:
Jason Clark
on

Part 2 of the Marketing Leadership series.

Part 1: Supercharge Your Value in the C-Suite
Part 2: How Does this Business Actually Make Money?
Part 3: A CMO's Prioritization System
Part 4: You Can't Cut Your Own Hair: Working With an Agency
Part 5: The Operating Cadence of a Focused Marketing Team
Part 6: How To Decide What To Do Next

Notes to a CMO: How does this business actually make money?

In Part 1, I made the case that a CMO's most important job is refusing to let tactics masquerade as strategy. The filter I use for every shiny new must-do starts with one question: which of our revenue levers does this touch?

Here's the catch. You can't answer that question if you don't actually know your revenue levers. And in my experience, most marketing leaders don't. Not really. They know the elevator version. They don't know the arithmetic.

That's what this article fixes.

The marketing plan is the wrong starting point

Most new CMOs do the natural thing in their first quarter: they audit the marketing.

  • The brand
  • The website
  • The funnel
  • The tech stack and social channels
  • The content calendar

All of that matters, but none of it is the starting point. A marketing audit tells you what marketing is doing. It cannot tell you what marketing is for. Only the revenue model can do that.

I've reviewed a lot of marketing plans over 20 years of agency work, and the most common failure isn't bad creative or weak channels. It's that the plan was written without ever touching the P&L. It reads like it could belong to any company in the industry, because in a sense it does.

Your marketing plan should be impossible to photocopy.

Your marketing plan should be impossible to photocopy. If a competitor could adopt it without edits, it isn't a strategy.

The 90-day exercise

Audit the money before the marketing.

Before you commit to priorities, pull the revenue apart three ways. This is the single most valuable thing I did in my first months in the CMO chair, and it requires nothing more sophisticated than your finance lead, a spreadsheet, and a few honest conversations.

Cut 1: Revenue by line of business. Which services or products actually carry the company? Which carry the margin, which carry the volume, and which carry mostly sentiment? Every company has an offering that leadership loves but the numbers don't. You need to define those before someone asks you to market it.

Cut 2: Revenue by client concentration. How much of the business depends on your top five clients? Concentration changes marketing's job. A company where 40% of revenue sits with a handful of accounts needs retention and relationship marketing long before it needs a lead-gen engine. Losing one anchor client can erase a year of new-business wins.

Cut 3: Revenue by acquisition source. Where did the current clients actually come from? Referrals, existing-client expansion, inbound, outbound, partnerships, sponsorships? Be suspicious of tidy answers here. Attribution is messy. But even a rough cut tells you which engines already work, which sputter, and which are lost effort.

Three cuts, one picture: where the money comes from today, and how fragile or durable each stream is. Write it on one page. You'll use it in every prioritization conversation going forward.

Cut revenue three ways before setting one priority.

Turn the company goal into marketing math

Now connect the picture to the target. This is where alignment between marketing strategy and business goals stops being a slide and becomes arithmetic.

When our leadership set a 10% year-over-year revenue growth goal, the useful move wasn't brainstorming campaigns. It was decomposing the number:

  • How much of the 10% comes from existing clients renewing (retention)?
  • How much from existing clients buying additional services (cross-division expansion)?
  • How much should be net-new business, and in which divisions?

Run that math and something clarifying happens: the growth target stops belonging to "the company" and starts belonging to specific revenue levers, each with a different marketing job attached.

  • Retention wants client communications and proof of value.
  • Expansion wants cross-selling, which means clients need to know everything you do, not just the thing they buy.
  • Net-new wants awareness and pipeline in the specific services with capacity and margin to grow.

For us, that exercise pointed marketing squarely at cross-division penetration and new business in our highest-margin services. Not because anyone in the room preferred those, but because the bottom line did.

The goal decides the marketing. Break the growth target into retention, expansion, and net-new.

The goal decides the marketing. You just have to do the division.

What this buys you

A revenue-grounded starting point pays off in three ways, and they compound.

Your priorities become defensible. When a division lead questions why their request sits behind another, you're not arguing taste or seniority. You're pointing at the one-page revenue picture and the growth math. People can disagree with arithmetic, but they have to bring their own arithmetic to do it. That changes the quality of the argument.

The shiny objects get easier. Remember the filter from Part 1. When the next must-do tactic arrives, you now have real levers to test it against. "Which revenue lever does this touch?" is a rhetorical question only until you have the list. Then it becomes a fast, fair test that most pitches fail on contact.

You earn a different seat at the table. The C-suite skepticism I mentioned in Part 1 (marketing as either irrelevant or magic) doesn't survive contact with a CMO who talks about client concentration and margin by service line. You stop being the person who asks for budget and start being the person who explains where growth comes from. That's the whole job, and it's a better meeting.

Do this next

If you're in your first 90 days, or your first honest reset:

  1. Book an hour with whoever owns the P&L. Ask for revenue by line of business, by client, and by acquisition source for the trailing two years.
  2. Compress what you learn onto one page. If it doesn't fit on one page, you haven't finished understanding it.
  3. Decompose the company's growth target into retention, expansion, and net-new. Attach a marketing job to each.
  4. Only then open the marketing plan.

Next in the series: what happens when everyone's priority is urgent, nobody filed a request, and the deadline was yesterday. The prioritization system that keeps a small team sane.

Jason Clark is Chief Marketing Officer at Tectonic, a digital services company. If mapping revenue to marketing sounds better with a second set of eyes, it's a conversation we enjoy.

One page of revenue context beats fifty pages of plans.

FAQ

How do you align marketing strategy with business goals?

Start with the revenue model, not the marketing audit. Break revenue down by line of business, client concentration, and acquisition source, then decompose the company's growth target into retention, expansion, and net-new. Each piece implies a specific marketing job; those jobs become your priorities.

What should a CMO do in their first 90 days?

Understand how the business makes money before changing how it markets. Meet the P&L owner, build a one-page revenue picture, and translate the growth target into marketing math. Audits of brand, website, and funnel come after, and they'll be sharper for the context.

What is revenue-driven marketing?

Marketing whose priorities are derived from the revenue model: which services carry margin, where growth is targeted, and which acquisition engines already work. It's the opposite of channel-first planning, where activities are chosen before anyone asks what they're supposed to move.

Why do marketing plans fail to support business goals?

Usually because they were written without considering the P&L. A plan that never references specific revenue levers defaults to generic industry activity, which makes it interchangeable with a competitor's plan and impossible to defend when priorities conflict.

Cracked earthVIA Studio

Curious about working with VIA Studio? Let us guide you.

Start Your Project Today